in
es
In
of
more
a
A
computers
increase
spreadsheet,
describe
the
a
of
out
million
wn
grid,
guage.
functions
col-
programmers
a
application
weapon
completely
a
making
first-class
formula”.
engineer
Instead,
ery
pro-
programming
w
in
,
Excel
that
,
propose
as
P
5).
spreadsheets
fundamental
programming
more
design
one.
people
without
e
Second,
v
that
e-usable
e
formulae”
It
w
their
lik
often
are
think
man
projected
choice
that
the
abstr
po
study
as
at
and
that
that
matrices
programming
,
“programming”,
uilt-in
programming
e
a
particular
as
programming
constraints)
of
functions
e
language
in-
of
xtual
by
Simon
ectors
meet
success
Ho
cluding
in
as
flat
the
in
Cogniti
programming
acts
v
principles
00].
simply
primary
(Section
v
a
programs
J
use.
Simply
cop
maintaining
single
numbers
language
v
get
in
the
in
e
o
Languages
approach
D.3.3
ef
doing
en
Excel
usable
emplo
cop
mec
a
are
Almost
com-
language,
in-
simple.
Pr
the
is
rather
ports
T
55
for
contr
ould
that
a
bring
also
e
imagine
as
this:
These
ability
subr
These
the
as
-defined
e
to
ut
spr
we
requirements
editor’
issue,
and
the
e
significant
programmer
end-user
v
objecti
uild
Uppsala,
,
Blac
an
e
therefore
xtension
them
are
er
er
we
to
the
vironments.
well-established
In
grate
idea
erms
per
Our
Amazingly
to
Functions
better
is
is
guage
important,
plainly
of
design
entire
most
elaborate
spread-
successful
xity:
a
rather
from
define
programmers,
w
y
not
are
professional
y
reusing
a
a
y
A2
Descriptors
Microsoft
of
programming
ple
of
people
cle
seem
ut
of
A2
end-user
cells
The
=
[
in
e
associated
Lan-
programmer
of
then
approach
armory
objecti
1
language
Univ
too
In
es,
an
programming
flat
our
is
of
[
cle
elaborate
v
most
or
part
of
e
se
[B
ersity
not
recent
describe
programming
the
true
with
It
done,
y
v
A3
Excel
that
usability
alone
Appr
is
langua
An
great
entional
e.
models
of
actions
D.3.2
a
is
imagine
the
discuss
to
Pr
secretary
emphasises
tasks.
and
ertheless
v
vious
lar
some
model”.
constructed
estment
an
a
Can
Cambr
guage
W
,
to
to
constructs
f
is
other
other
their
technology?
the
the
a
though,
a
Cambr
lik
users
analytic
usability
ha
the
User
es
programmers
of
con
objecti
procedures,
e
additional
and
v
commercially
Abstract
and
tines
physicist,
or
ork
programming-lik
“b
,
a
ho
with
the
alan.blackwell@cl.cam.ac.uk
defined
In
use
act
them
es
professional
idge
]:
and
this
gely
approach
rapidly;
to
cells
our
xtension
to
Notations
project
5/9
which
e
equations
that
maintain
2.75
is
ell
as
Indeed,
e
our
sheet.
International
in
b
the
h
er
not
Margaret
v
End-user
,
let
the
strange
hanism
sup-
languages
languages
functions
apart
to
in
to
form,
v
;
is
of
this
as
from
e
and
use
the
e
Models
A1
lection
turns
as
o
Oregon
use
a
no
the
is
paste
possible
broader
.
werful
spreadsheets
to
the
often
Univ
v
H.1.2
an
ones.
for
criterion.
defined
;
a
programmers
formulae
lan-
into
our
ager
to
2005,
Jones
via
.
ol
these
of
Thought
design
Dimensions
the
program
C
language.
the
outnum-
suggest
defined
systems
“write
4).
antage.
only
for
of
there
y-and-paste
this
are
of
e
for
not
most
the
on
appear
Pr
a
Languages,Design
teacher
b
that
r
than
com-
yed
spreadsheet
interested
all
people
of
treating
W
ing
it
than
million
ersity
v
ogramming
alone
commercial
(functional)
idge
applicable
and
programming
the
a
=
f
to
Programming
y
a
functions
:
(with
write
-
Subject
,
s
and
their
programming
belie
tar
.
programmers
elopments
is
language,
T
principles.
kw
in
and
cogniti
as
tak
to
more
not
spreadsheet
describe
y
formulae.
language,
user
is
then,
]:
W
project
General
reach
in
support
features—
man-
that
w
find
is
v
lan-
the
you
recognised
Intr
compatibility
in
and
,
user
user
v
b
simonpj@microsoft.com
of
the
major
programmers,
people,
y-and-
com-
W
particularly
trained
to
de
first
oduction
Alan
demonstrate
themselv
a
e
end-user
who
v
odd
often
cells
*
programming
basic
techniques.
end
objecti
xpected
to
with
spreadsheets
it
one
k
result-
fect,
.
classifications—
2003
burnett@cs.orst.edu
(Section
accountant,
—
third
pared
vie
]:
gramming
v
design
is
1
ber
man
by
models,
abstraction
also
xcept
den
on
(ICFP’03),
used
lac
nett
a
based
act
number
of
the
en
may
b
thousands
olution
=
is
A1-32
ariable
spreadsheet
use
User/machine
is
oac
closely
g
end-user
merits
a
Third
and
“v
programming-language
f
of
system
Excel
printing
State
that
ocedur
,
functional
v
Thus,
we
point
Languages
er
these
v
inte
F
in
model
ything
“bolt-on”.
programmers
that
need
e
Categories
the
y
spreadsheet
act,
especially
cells
job
man
e
widely
the
form
and
adv
to
U.S.
-Centred
functions
Functional
[Nar93].
the
v
v
2003
Attention
w
xtremely
Language
Functional
can
[
we
a
=
that
e
eadsheets
programming
is
we
and
pre
30th
ne
v
almost
as
uild
Research,
ou-
constraints.
paper
spreadsheet
we
This
in
of
get
and
olving
is
the
xtensions
ersions
and
The
support
this
une
—
“end-user”
one
a
second
as
to
,
benefits
functions
Conference
the
Bur
alues,
as
a
3
w
for
te
From
ogramming
users
+
patibility
this
spreadsheet
be
program.
f
due
features
AB
yton
w
attrib
that
read
programming
of
to
y
interaction.
formative
mak
design
the
wledge
appr
into
required
is
the
w
applied
orks.
tend
DP95,
to
in
fort
the
programmers;
generalizations
CW00,
users’
actor
of
ef
on
v
-defined
attempting
theoretical
order
ork
-
abstraction
throughout
this
v
sho
that
of
changing
grammers
(CDs)
amount
b
Dimensions
fore
all
that
mak
w
between
wn
much
Despite
in
list
dencies
capabilities.
an
e
w
Role-
of
by
important
it
design
communication
cells
.
are
y
guages
is
need?
xplicit
what
language
of
beha
An
Ho
Attention
learnt,
can
are
e
empirical
Dimensions
in
channel
problem
y
focus
xpressi
dimension
e
prac-
to
to
a
summarizing
sharp
sub-sections
our
group
design
hard
and
w
to
com-
or
referred
a
isibility
focus
Dimensions
v
who
an
be
of
:
programming
decisions
e
been
formulae
mak
can
ving
although
be
Our
The
briefly
of
e
gotten
CDs
tasks.
be
F
to
V
inferred?
the
design
“When
programming
may
has
ne
and
user
v
it
kno
engaged
f
of
juxtaposability
both
usability
or
mostly-ignored
ha
that
are
to
not
e
thing”,
v
maintain
depen-
is
programming
w
possible
e
uting
Is
iscosity
to
[GP96,
ming
b
concepts
so
ers
it?
is
contrib
to
ed
order
—
possibility
design,
xpressing
ge
syntax,
empirical
2.1
lan-
One
sistenc
in
Cogniti
so
the
summarises
of
in
studies
guages
project,
a
the
‘care-
to
traditional
pro-
are
information
the
approach,
can
Abstraction
inform
rest
e
lan-
language
ha
rather
functional
pro-
e
functions
is
in
Why
a
programmers
gle
tw
the
the
lies
points
consistency
dispersed,
ork
not?
a
of
centered
out
research
function
function
is
allocating
to
w
component
defined
ay
remind
or
CDs
code
into
to
design
be
repeated.
in
Do
eloped
b
the
these
[GP96])
the
true
o
e
fundamental
spreadsheet.
of
enumerates
xts
of
The
not
means
dimension
e
els
gradient
utes
to
benefit
is
programming
to
the
each
it
approaches
Notations
whole?
of
The
conte
human
Can
Another
assess
Although
e
useful
strained
2
suc-
people
w
W
some
decisions
en
it
y
user
est-
le
has
This
com-
people
CDs
ho
more
vie
genuine
this
,
design
empirical
at
not
of
which
be-
problem
of
xisting
informs
help
e
guage
see
a
issues
is
rele
usefully
psychology
specialised
whether
uncertain.
symbolic?
reader
Progressi
some
the
vironment
from
required
small
and
the
y
wing
also
—
that
vious,
language.
perceptual
vie
by-side
of
grate
adopt
v
rele
e
may
programming
find
comes
the
ution
that
indication
to
required
of
paper
v
project
we
continued
of
programming
v
on
Expressed
the
Figure
about
ge
of
language
Can
the
solv
these
for
e
at
same
to
belief
to
mers,
is
ely
vidence
for
must
the
e
a
programming
intended
to
relates
What
that
e
v
[BG87,
as
them
ay
a
ork
only
must
is
find
Furthermore
end
mitment
de
functional
dra
e
changed.
the
language
main
that
design
w
human
specified
.
de-
uct
hope
e
v
al
inferred?”
lik
maximum
utes
later
the
parts
of
learnt,
a
lar
instead
o
parameters.
W
clear
visible
our
ha
point
a
we
as
tw
this
because
sin-
Error
con-
design
at
groundw
kno
humans.
when
change?
be
sharpens
to
such
relati
on
the
xtent
con-
repeated
w
y
research
the
of
y
Dimensions
considering
w
hard
properties
of
the
fort
commercial
signers
v
o
researchers
its
in
than
this
an
our
program-
guided
progress
mak
survi
group,
are
is
(excer
from
b
vide
estigations
I
abstraction?
it
xamples
whose
can
compare
can
their
am
namely
HCI
problem,
consciously
es
documented
maximize
pro
is
e
procedural
y
w
of
much
to
spreadsheet
to
per
it
in
acti
es’?
Be
to
v
indicated
subset
It
[NC85].
ork,
v
CDs
fragments
of
of
of
1.
possible
xtending
as
is
a
W
dependenc
this
address
for
easily
in
e
of
e
using
ery
are
this
code
least
language
v
design
projects
ws
ha
for
will?
y
are
that,
xample,
v
e
-proneness
e
2
Is
people
encouraging,
directions?
o
so
concepts
–
ment
concerns
from
endea
on
ant
ne
ho
be
e
xperimental
e
side-
are
ques-
programming
—
that
T
design
v
end
y
CD
the
ut
Figur
e
amiliar
it
we
the
functional
to
design
do
including
single
of
find.
f
that
is
the
spreadsheets
who
the
functional
gnitive
often
informally
approach
of
o
the
we
language
solving
in
ut
deficiencies
or
that
feedback
is
programming.
concept
while
psychology
e
ecuted
function
professional
usability
more
or
programming
check
spreadsheet
viscosity
people
obtain
process.
tured
been
search
people
are
form
display),
to
frame
to
prod-
e
that
human-computer
se
w
code
is
enough
y
oach
ing
program
projects
CDs
e
fields
b
ge
the
-defined
(e.g.
and
should
design
our
a
to
seem
This
lar
them
ed
V
that
act)
successfully
the
con-
may
adopted
-centr
other
non-psychologists
less
follo
important
human
ery
a
structure.
w
BBC02]).
doing”?
en
particularly
o
is
vidence
b
xample
mistak
of
functions
technology
programming
a
tills
is,
w
induce
v
designers.
language
en
all
studies
—
at
is
our
“good
research
which
tak
into
signature
an
e
k
v
ork
x
little
,
goal
vidual
y
simultaneously
vi-
ultimately
that
notation
ely
e
In
from
Consistenc
ducti
we
Indi
of
code
v
readily
concern,
to
1
research.
the
features
in
that
BCA
is
important
pro-
terms
conciseness.
and
the
Comparati
be
tw
gramming
v
result,
such
ork
is
succeed
y
most
to
the
users
other
from
discussions
the
w
will
w
channel.
problem
CA02,
especially
vironments,
Cogniti
the
guidance
frame
of
w
we
is
the
v
by
The
our
and
part
A
frame
program
of
are
usefulness
w
–
useful
a
ery
ne
detailed
can
end
language
program-
W
xpress
tically
our
v
use
languages.
partially-complete
considers
solving,
v
e
As
w
the
This
of
a
other
lan-
attrib
design
time
a
course,
Man
change
project.
Can
design
ay
these
when
the
usable.
are
our
the
Does
on
viour
In
important
languages,
the
in
v
HCI
ultimate
.
in
ut
consistenc
much
theories
(before-the-f
use
v
Is
considered
been
the
eness
to
v
its
in
This
rules,
find
vocab
least
of
BG03].
amount
design
oted
xpressi
cogniti
serv
to
(assuming
a
has
v
v
emphasise
particularly
.
to
w
from
be
xample
Hidden
a
and
en
designer
benefit
the
tion:
de
e
[LGAH02,
ay
informal
programming-language
ha
e
Premature
inte-
When
a
in
are
e
user
is
be
recent
Highly-e
wn
w
an
for
of
contrib
Our
generally
language
part
practical
encapsulated?
Cogniti
who
Excel.
-defined
use
is
programming
depends
[GP96].
concrete,
in
user
lar
or
the
in
ut
though,
Co
ut
ersion
guided
spreadsheets.
information
research
by
minimum
om
ut
being
future
their
into
the
in
“Ho
created.
dis-
some
e
because
successfully
users.
re-
v
b
hard,
that
aluation
sistenc
used
idea
locations
vis-
ronments
Because
the
-
a
programming-language
the
dur
been
end
principles
designers,
It
or
The
user
kno
of
applicable
re-
paper
in
ulary
fr
by
of
vironment
be
programming
ob-
about
ut
ertly
the
v
as
If
pted
a
ork
cess
most
struc-
because
a
ant.
to
the
cous,
e
in
v
w
e
es
the
v
community
wn
perform
de
(e.g.,
a
puters,
language
yond
lacks
amiliar
HLMC96]).
e
of
Excel
puter
its
f
and
the
highly
elopers
com-
are
o
,
ho
ery
v
of
w
ef
with
ho
not
contained
to
GPB91,
already
discussion
was
by
been
rest
that
are
e
,
elihood
ha
language
specific
“”
language
vices
.
xperts
functions
.
cost
justify
On
v
that
dif
4.0
As
ving
-defined
ws
to
lead
estment
v
miliar
[Bla02].
The
user
and
it
can
guage
re
case
b
First
the
A
formulation
v
I
de
This
in
ealed
in
(after
reduce
payof
he
v
Figure
“I
cost
as
In
CDs
-the-f
quite
what
to
complementary
v
so
a
other
ere:
;
Our
v
w
blocks
V
tice:
course,
duplicated
repetition,
benefits.
The
v
in
their
vide
,
represented
form
a
o
machine
only
comple
in
to
alue
v
counter
of
to
and-paste
remind
A
their
potential
is
a
ha
ealed
their
if
the
accomplishing
another
v
acti
w
more
he
ferent
that
e
and
standard
risk
“Insert...
or
still
accounting
the
v
Our
easier
K
curb
columns,
as
the
a
user
will
natural
what
and
to
aluable,
In
understanding
an
of
of
entually
The
the
Excel
concentrating
it
sub-
pro
intervie
might
Users
summative
you
fessional
“pro
model
analyse
time
a
has
ha
ing
the
are
User
design
one
than
the
our
w
is
application
ha
9
y-
to
y
user
within
language
dur
by
to
spans
with
tasks.
guage
)
vities
-defined
will
task.
more
it
such
allo
of
see
the
a
of
all,
v
maintenance.
use
on).
e
of
the
R
ork
libraries
ailable
D
its
the
reducing
be
estments
that
y
problems.
y
can
f
(
,
and
model
these
It
v
ceive
at
ming.
e
so-called
of
is
user
(
of
with
se
au-
w
benefit:
v
isual
v
v
sheet”),
studies,
decisions
ability
v
semantics
tw
principles
in
particular
v
find
to
when
we
e
an
Ev
BLAN
Attention
an
!
macros
ant
a
ef
is
an
,
strength
the
fort
estment
this
erf
near
is
a
firm
A
”
fs.
amount
support
unless
the
6
designers,
checking
with
The
ork
e
in
to
function
ro
must
en
”
high,
at
code
payof
ed
support
zero
on
a
is
and
for
es
Excel
has
in
e
as
that
updated,
the
the
questions
f
supported
will
psychological
my
sections
a
(
in
to
e
too
v
the
as
,
of
V
model
will
is
users
(
Ev
directly
code
by
or
the
M
3.1
e
2.2
usiness-critical
which
functions
a
as
(right-click
language.
granted
v
[BB02,
payof
act,
as
them
arnings
documented
making
e”
the
mak
User
repeatedly
will
high
Real
f
spreadsheets
e
fs
e
aimed
v
of
for
is
the
tions
xpected
simply
the
by
f
beha
taking
this
to
Attention
ut
act,
look
the
that
the
and
quo
E
w
of
6
v
of
wn
(notably
formula
v
frame
in
decisions.
a
e
of
BLAN
specific
in
aluation,
Excel
the
xceeds
and
albeit
Basic
foresee
e
libraries.
programming
trouble
s
6
fort
The
distrib
potential
o
payof
high
issues.
that
isual
for
f
with
to
user
ork,
as
encourages
ut
est
program-
e
real
do
tools
ealed
of
your
a
because
tak
JITted
out
to
needed.
vides
(hiding
will
What
a
functions.
collapsing
decision
intellectual
that
in
?
not
Reduce
insights
only
xity-management
reuse
e
functions
important
can
for
and
again:
auditor
be
of
be.
)
problems
r
lan-
.
cog-
a
The
the
.
the
encapsulated
v
made
of
v
e
e
F
:
The
ws
frame
change),
between
v
yet
tailored
XLM
expertise.
ut
of
prac-
to
and
the
ac-
function’
macros”,
for
ha
a
,
CDs
be
language
intellectual
U
at
spreadsheet
en
-
v
act
users
Local
;
these
atten-
actual
already
Here
end
er
granularity
be
with
functions
e,
same
grid
function
concerns
v
the
such
empirical
manifest,
instead
R
and
ha
ed
folk
v
to
a
imperati
In
1
pro-
place.
rently
the
problems
property
to
ormance.
good
w
b
via
(resistance
a
percei
w
“XLM
ould
the
and
of
can
e
of
critical.
xt,
Is
terms
in
encapsulates
deal
costs
attentional
ws
A
that
programmer
ork
not
e
1).
management
be
that
bodies
of
as
fecti
out
we
as
risk
-defined
tak
with
all
user’
v
standpoint.
up
aluation
is
is
be
ordinary
thereby
it
so
This
The
3
will
cur
on
vidence
sharper
a
v
pr
making
w
code,
Basic
with
in-
need
e
that
great
places
hundreds
to
will
abstract
Attention
are
A
XLM
e
epetition.
abstraction
cope
to
all
a
attention-in
v
macros
xplicit,
with
,
not
a
as
y
v
f
est
name,
ailable
Z
or
pro-
sequential
design
produce
is
estment
ork,
y
groups
groups,
will
xtend
cannot
intervie
e
More
superficially
define
must
such
in
hand,
protecting
performance
problems
goal
aged.
scenes,
in
Suppose
in
payof
no
from
-
by
and
e
ork.
I
tree,
byte
programmer
niti
status
e
-
still
ne
reasonable
simulation
been
because
ha
x
CD
that
v
formula
their
1
v
costs?
years,
learning
E
w
that
of
types
re-use
e
w
on
[Bla02],
err
estate
the
cogniti
v
viour
6
goal
w
model’
E
research
we
User
remain.
thus
comple
a
these
case
v
cop
ay
6
by
,
to
is
,
ed
to
encapsulate
colleagues.
-optimum.
-defined
during
errors.
laid
generally
Cogniti
a
their
formula.
lan-
err
ay
in
with
oid
pay
ascribed
an
easy
not
Our
In-
be:
ork,
Whether
3.2
the
spend
compiled
F
changed
by
“Excel
programming
has
of
-defined
crack
w
v
pro
designers
major
sa
of
conte
are
le
management.
f
to
use
per
raising
y
to
ef
re-use.
er
E
it
most
the
of
call
shape,
definition
is
Earlier
w
important
e
discussed
cell
ef
f
in
v
approaches
tar
an
and
tools,
not
be
the
the
the
supply
e
language,
of
been
number
of
complementary
also
do
idea
formula
be
re
more
estment
payof
v
After
U
M
issues
risk.
or
prescripti
,
vest
the
ok
first
w
enumeration
in
that
hard
vity
analyses
xpected
to
an
if
duced
by
it
be
the
multiple
required
vide
User
ed
fort
tiresome.
,
the
v
human
applied
r
be
for
en
Excel
In
v
also
or
v
model,
in
customer
e
V
b
of
define
e
re
this
fs
both
oted
v
”
in
or
function
named
domain-specific
in
performance
orksheet:
v
ment
-defined
fort
a
before
,
grid
ef
F
fort
act)
operty
one
for
programming
whate
a
O
and
simple
designers.
programmers.
:
and
attentional
will
to
calls
can
which
pro-
domain
our
that
use
user
copied
actual
en
Intellectual
1
vides
xtent
payof
apparent.
and
years
the
immensely
orksheet
estment
at
The
pro
s
Excel
be
and
F
some
v
e
here.
b
follo
intellectual
A
as
functions
is
and
f,
identify
ef
potential
using
Excel’
the
more
w
with
spe-
achie
sheet.
e-use
be
A
payof
by
error
be
macro
,
section
fine-grain
re-used
the
offs?
)
be
to
f.
v
we
be
if
proneness
0
literally
future,
to
the
isual
modified
a
estment
too
user
libraries
from
Of
a-
team
great.
formulae;
y
maybe
estate
ving
function
it
ailed
such
functions
described
in
pro
in
of
tak
is
spreadsheet
...
them
alidated
or
from
ute
sa
“If
to
(see
you
to
the
a
In
attentional
found
it
viscosity
the
v
user
S
belie
odds
ha
v
2,
as
copied
formula,
-centr
in
is
repeated
fs
ors
the
models,
de
of
,
which
w
we
on
tab,
cost
3
w
w
the
producti
both
so
e
cific
formula
one
or
such
design
This
confused
xpression
P
v
to
clearly
vide
v
a
olv
in
Encapsulate
when
oking
attention
ersions
of
poten-
finance)
to
needs
dience
tion
Excel;
)
e
end
rather
in
consider
man
the
e
in
code
otection.
w
decisions
are
In
v
?
v
)
1
macro
Dimensions
tially
blanks
s
functions,
spreadsheets
formula
9
which
Real
certain
get
to
actions
Attention
not
if
their
-defined
ants
that
rele
generality
in
ar
must
of
re-use
create
w
is
reduces
too
we
can
man
similar
to
place?
idea.
S
later
source
What
els
good
costs
D
2
concrete
As
against
not
est-
the
BBC02].
it
functions
for
Basic.
program
the
code,
cost
=
o
consider
ef
orse,
K
v
consider
,
estate
this
in
in
tervie
w
tuiti
es
considers
v
are,
consider
alues.
of
the
cells.
practical
reason,
amount
estment
cells.
er
for
user
the
Z
v
or
can
pick
functions,
w
it
-pr
function
substantial
“macro”.
The
e
domain-specific
Programmers
enable
O
language
s
(
there
While
language
encour
ar
must
to
user
finite
that
again
for
which
to
is
Behind
model
not
good
pr
select
was
tool
as
the
estment
The
g
established,
is
parameters,
spreadsheet
in
be
;
spr
=
to
third
the
(approximately
or
orksheets,
xample.
requires
simple
get
for
y
(2)
short.
a
users’
3.3
Not
V
A
multiple
hardly
Figure
order
maintenance
f
x
v
ould
to
Cell
ing
W
payof
y
as
3
that
get
function
under
additional
the
get
first
f
k
256
a
er
more.
b
The
users
a
intermediate
lead
than
ery
reduced.
and
ground
should
stance
a
we
CD
standard
critical.
of
first
imple-
that
mak
learning)
in
ed
“function
:
Costs
from
which
only
understand
columns
same
Excel
much
Deb
some
par
costs
acilities
it
of
set
in
our
which
contrib
or
contains
which
ith
worksheets
design,
specified
comfortable
w
of
beha
is
of
and
bottom
these
the
has
cost
get
people
the
ugging
paradigm
consistenc
eeping
it
instead
mak
fer
of
computational
can
(imperati
oid
features
those
be
ne
consistency
w
v
stood
other”.
infix
sheet,
.
Section
VB
w
appears
required
this
applying
is
ocation
their
the
a
already
and
lo
of
or
belo
cells,
,
VB
refers
er
with
contains
aluable
feature
the
asset
dif
es
Excel
of
.
their
these
lik
of
rule,
call
this
using
tasks
prerequisites
Excel
with
—
items
input
isual
because
only
w-cost
a
means
function
our
can
v
does
3.
Section
te
sho
formula
item
e
ho
the
dif
programming
function
w
costs
is
b
long-term
-
wing
the
a
has
of
we
for
audit
v
cost
)
y
functions
issues
these:
prereq-
6.)
as
can
tied
vs
to
the
from
v
(in
to
2
users
2
[adv
cell
orkbook
use
the
Basic
them
already
v
Figure
vironment
pr
the
ground
v
y
prerequisite
,
e
Our
sho
is
and
more
of
in
insights
w
The
the
audience
learnt,
at
,
already
equisite
sho
people
multiple
those
lo
ealed
orksheets
(block
w
calculations
instance”
sheet
alues
v
Our
v
paradigm
w
in
of
grid
not
function
V
.
Recall
wer
link
orksheet
(
10
require
be
v
the
in
function
are
sheet
3
than
use
we
location;
one
C
do
in
In
programming
orksheet.
re-
of
the
will
Ho
requisites.
to
wn
one
es
the
second
ut
is
function
and
an
oppor
.
M
e
systematically
with
inferred?”
dif
yed
B
is
and
of
nothing
a
in
F
enumerated
V
the
-
e
write
then,
consists
which
in
v
an
A
ing
distinguishing
lo
1
use
lik
under
result
design
answer
act
The
up
contains
ho
to
b
more
orkbook
cells);
the
to
to
w
-
airly
at
viously
the
w
tar
Ho
mak
to
where
section,
to
dif
The
cells
prerequisites,
a
rest
notation
F
audience
of
v
audience
and
our
in
or
not
deb
In
(top)
prerequisites
tasks
deb
,
est-
skills
ne
figure
instance
another
whose
The
who
y
has
follo
question.
e
i.e.,
v
functions
consistency
uilt-in
multiple
instance;
w
zero.
displayed
determined
es.
succeed
able
F
by
-
ut
surprising
audience
,
panel
of
into
functions,
learning
much
w
intended
Some
is
the
costs
cell
a
Using
model
design
v
estment.
uted
applications
user
v
-defined
e);
2
func-
much
of
rests.
kno
the
ery
we
parameter
function,
the
estment)
in
learning
attention
-
accessible
the
tions.
just
our
item
on
nothing
relati
attempting
one
its
the
b
is
B
result
and
create,
in
umping
erts
Adv
3.2
high
a
the
at
the
establishing
be
ws.
i-
sho
functions
ugging
viour
ut
ed
e
In
w
declar
w
infer
further
has
the
who
pplying
“b
deb
implementation
the
to
to
than
data
must
ati
is
quires
sometimes
this
Basic
Figur
eadsheet,
is
defined
that
to
of
uisite
costs
of
4.1
(bottom)
(V
to
already
func-
A
little
,
which
re
ferent
en
in
approach
instance,
of
the
an
of
through
2
vide
e
our
computations
cell
suit
site
ut
prerequisites.
the
of
in
of
a
function
in
the
modify
CDs
contains
Studio);
v
an
upper
is
xpected
managing
accomplish,
by
with
Excel?
C
A
the
final
Adv
adigm
function
a
of
a
e
our
2
W
and
that
to
isual
comple
con
meetings
C3
w
e
than
ariety
to
ro
the
has
preferred...
prerequisites,
total
while
alternati
are
fold-
in-
ocation
the
upon
in
mastered
answers
file
of
long-li
by
implementation
to
more
is
primary
is
v
the
C
other
wers
its
formulae.
v
to
each
and
to
v
slo
User
[YBDZ97].
Others
pre-
isual
design
in
copy/paste
these
gi
of
you
one
in
abo
—
them
attention
B
2.
skill
these
lo
in
alue,
is
Excel
the
ferent
design
ahrenheit
has
we
to
rather
the
of
information.
y
Basic.
s
separate
“When
table
spread-
orksheet.
to
1
interface
Studio
a
(ha
xpected
not
Our
is
e
(deb
a
deplo
easier
xt
by
which
e
increasing
design
ay
of
by
by
v
-defined
dif
what
zero,
wer
model
number
e
w
and
”
is
a
added
print-
a
gi
One
be
scaf
uild
3
the
isual
terms
logically
parameter
the
,
ordinary
are
U
that
v
that
with
B
the
costs,
et
those
be
tion
pre
not
skills.
Excel
commercially-
are
be
be
some
F
our
is
b
than
V
under
lik
continuously
in
“Excel
lo
the
elements
such
and
f
Section
arbitrary
of
v
Basic
-
it
sheeting
e
.
is
all
Centigrade.
the
can
also
formula
who
(1)
A
,
be
lands
list
other
from
costs
the
sheet
enables
the
w
not
F
in
functions
trail;
e
so
users
ha
the
risk,
an
can
of
functions
w
designers
.
greater
at
design
en
the
the
users
stand
payof
In
w
in
our
orksheet
call
that
the
instance
is
our
w
Excel’
ho
ha
use
w
users
e
mentation
xpressed
input
w
orksheets
stand
design
and
operators;
As
is
ferent
a
up
man
4
anced
in
Excel,
using
to
zero)
moderate
language
Since
understanding
means
plied
the
anced
ho
design,
.
which
orld:
break
the
of
benefit.
ambitious
which
arose
the
ugging
er
managing
identify
en
for
is
it
of
just
an
orksheets
isual
that
and
because
the
f
The
ferent
writing
orksheet
antage]
2
our
also
more
rule,
tar
is
v
bring
The
Excel
CD
-
be
2
proposing
be
w
beha
and
ugging
of
-defined
e
is
w
by
w
pro
barrier
list
that
thoroughly
because
v
ed
necessary
functions
f
if
number
users
ap-
V
tar
f,
an
that
tackle
our
altered
computed
be
package
v
it
b
operations,
group,
ment
temperatures
v
costs.
link
first
mulae,
groups,
ork
is
defined
o
VB
more
less
also
y
the
the
real
consistent
this
a
it
(W
high.
CD
user
a
ugger).
as
1
prerequisites,
while
w
3.3,
the
as
orksheet,
T
payof
yours
for
k
user
been
to
performance;
an
4
offs:
in
comfortable
each
ferences
is
procedures
sual
v
w
related
to
a
...
instead
ery
e
can
should
or
tunity
The
e
both
to
e
tar
a
are
it
B
e
retrie
that
.
e
y
discuss
v
w
attention
skills;
v
the
users
idea
v
cost
into
ws
should
able
oft-repeated
intermediate
list.
to
1,
prerequisites
language
These
look
tar
current
pay
workbook
vie
w
audience,
a
the
programming
that
learning
can
wer
One
design,
(3)
replicate
looking
Our
is
S
de-
principle
v
user
ok
other
time
a
and
the
sheet
follo
helps
by
accustomed.
v
not
written
its
fs.
with
formula
ceived
functions
status
e
mentary
C
not
payof
short,
es
to
sheets
calculation
cal-
can
since
by
(“Is
potentially
one
orksheets.
2
be.
answer
with
has
too.
wing
same
when
generality
w
possible
it
spreadsheets
re-
sible
formulae
e
is
another
w-risk
sheet.
mak
The
can
kno
ay
sheet’
01],
contain
y
w
tion
a
up
breaks
3
function
of
bar)
in
orksheets,
xisting
the
be
x-
defines
support
not
other
this
design
algebraic
code
V
design
wn
ordinary
the
less
of
must
for
design
roles
Cells
of
vices
the
must
-defined
the
ganised
of
1
al-
with
Excel’
in
using
hearts
ha
from,
b
y
Step
to
these
are
the
the
to
input
v
than
basic
our
the
ery
links.
that
of
underlying
this
all
ork
gets
well,
the
v
their
it
+
ne
for
to
other
ver
w
1!
we
In
at
c
v
the
-defined
maintain
alues.
function
.
wizard”
or
instance
mainstream
before
lightly
or
costs
A1
,
the
xisting
the
user
the
,
as
call
in
v
a
function
commitment.
define
y
reuse
e
plicit
essiveness
.
e
w
items
e
much
are
,
the
recursi
attempts
the
first
an
function,
continu-
xpressing
ould
ne
cross-sheet
upon
o
align
the
y
prerequisites
consistenc
sends
b
defined.
this:
the
and
of
an
usability
re-in
w
In
immediate
each
commercial
(a
(2)